Breastfeeding Medicine

Physicians blogging about breastfeeding

Mountains and hills in infant nutrition

with 2 comments

How do you imagine the Alps? Let’s have a look in Switzerland, Austria, Italy, France or Germany. Here you will find a wonderful panorama view: the mountains, lush green meadows, the flora and fauna, the rocks and stones, but also cultural elements like alpine farms, the goats and cows.

The Alps

Breastfeeding is, in a way, the “Alps” in infant nutrition -- and not only in nutrition.

Breastfeeding is, in a way, the “Alps” in infant nutrition — and not only in nutrition. Just as the Alps are not only about the mountain tops, but the whole landscape, so is breastfeeding is more than nutrition. The german word “stillen”, which means “soothing” actually expresses this much more clearly than the word breastfeeding. It is interplay between mother and child with many contributing factors: nutrition, immunisation and most of all an intensive bonding between a mother and her child. It is the seamless transition from the intra-uterine environment with constant contact and constant nourishment to extra-uterine world, with lots of skin-to skin contact and a very frequent feeding. It is the normal adaptation process of a newborn, a baby, and at the same time the normal adaptation process of the mother.

I am from the Netherlands. And we, in the Netherlands, are longing for the Alps. We already have the beginning. The Vaalserberg, at the borders of the Netherlands, Germany and Belgium, would be suitable. But it is not quite what it should be. So this mountain should be heightened-up a little bit. We could make it a 100% higher. That would do, wouldn’t it?
Now this Vaalserberg is 326 meter above sea-level (360 meters with the tower on it), and even if we would heighten it up 100% it still doesn’t have the height of the Alps. Try to further heighten it up? You have to be honest: It is not just the height: essential elements of the Alps are failing in the Netherlands. Flora and Fauna will never be that of the Alps landscape. And you cannot solve this problem with heightening up. Of course it is a good alternative, when you cannot have the Alps. It is a good recreation area, it has its own value for the people in the region and for holidays, but you cannot honestly say it is the Alps (even when some hotel owners want us to believe this – they call their hotel: Alpenblik – Alpview).

vaalserberg

The Vaalserberg will never be the Alps

And so we have the parallel: formula is infant nutrition of acceptable quality, and in principle this quality can be improved. But as much as you can (and should) enhance this quality, it never will reach the standard of the original. It brings risks with it and disadvantages, for mother, child and society. When we do have the quality of the Alps, we should not be content with the Vaalserberg.

Elien Rouw is a physician in Bühl, Germany, and a member of ABM

Opinions expressed on the ABM blog are those of individual members, not the organization as a whole.

Written by elienrouw

November 3, 2011 at 2:49 pm

2 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. This is a wonderful post! Thanks!

    Amber @ Au Coeur

    November 3, 2011 at 3:03 pm

  2. Elien, This is a marvelous analogy. It is clever, and even funny, and God knows after 2 full days of ABM Board meetings which have been quite fruitful here in Miami, we need some humor, so thank you for that!!! But it brings it home so well. Yes–the hills of Connecticut are lovely, and beautiful to walk in, but they will never be the Rockies of Colorado. And so infant formulas are needed for some babies, and as you stated so well should be improved as best as our science allows, but no matter what is done, it will never be “the real deal”!!! So thank you for this insight and humor on what is such a significant point!!! Kathie Marinelli, ABM Board Member

    kmarinellimd

    November 3, 2011 at 8:42 pm


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: